Gasification vs Incineration
This gasification vs incineration comparison outlines the process differences and key factors to assess when choosing a waste treatment system. Suitability depends on the feedstock, site, energy demand and operating requirements. Contact AGS Energy to discuss your proposed application.
Mobile Users : Scroll right on table to view all columns.
| Feature | Incineration | AGS gasification approach |
|---|---|---|
| Process | Direct combustion of waste with sufficient oxygen. | Gasification under controlled, reduced-oxygen conditions, followed by use of the generated gases within the thermal process. |
| Feedstock suitability | Depends on plant design, waste composition and permit conditions. | Requires assessment of composition, moisture, calorific value and preparation requirements. |
| External energy | Start-up and supplementary fuel requirements depend on the feedstock and operating conditions. | Designed for autothermic operation with suitable feedstock after start-up. Auxiliary equipment still requires energy. |
| Energy recovery | Can recover useful heat and generate electricity. | Recovers useful heat. Electricity generation or cooling requires additional equipment. |
| Footprint | Depends on capacity, storage, treatment equipment and site layout. | Modular equipment layout; the complete installation footprint must be established for each project. |
| Solid residues | Bottom ash and air pollution control residues require appropriate management. | Char, ash and filtration residues depend on feedstock and operation; testing determines suitable management routes. |
| Maintenance and staffing | Depends on equipment, automation and operating regime. | Requires planned maintenance, trained operators and appropriate supervision. |
| Emissions | Requires suitable emissions controls and monitoring under applicable permit conditions. | Requires suitable emissions controls and monitoring under applicable permit conditions. |
| Performance comparison | Assess net useful energy, availability and whole-life costs for the intended application. | Assess on the same basis, using defined feedstock conditions and supported performance data. |
