Gasification vs Incineration

This gasification vs incineration comparison outlines the process differences and key factors to assess when choosing a waste treatment system. Suitability depends on the feedstock, site, energy demand and operating requirements. Contact AGS Energy to discuss your proposed application.

Mobile Users : Scroll right on table to view all columns.

Feature Incineration AGS gasification approach
Process Direct combustion of waste with sufficient oxygen. Gasification under controlled, reduced-oxygen conditions, followed by use of the generated gases within the thermal process.
Feedstock suitability Depends on plant design, waste composition and permit conditions. Requires assessment of composition, moisture, calorific value and preparation requirements.
External energy Start-up and supplementary fuel requirements depend on the feedstock and operating conditions. Designed for autothermic operation with suitable feedstock after start-up. Auxiliary equipment still requires energy.
Energy recovery Can recover useful heat and generate electricity. Recovers useful heat. Electricity generation or cooling requires additional equipment.
Footprint Depends on capacity, storage, treatment equipment and site layout. Modular equipment layout; the complete installation footprint must be established for each project.
Solid residues Bottom ash and air pollution control residues require appropriate management. Char, ash and filtration residues depend on feedstock and operation; testing determines suitable management routes.
Maintenance and staffing Depends on equipment, automation and operating regime. Requires planned maintenance, trained operators and appropriate supervision.
Emissions Requires suitable emissions controls and monitoring under applicable permit conditions. Requires suitable emissions controls and monitoring under applicable permit conditions.
Performance comparison Assess net useful energy, availability and whole-life costs for the intended application. Assess on the same basis, using defined feedstock conditions and supported performance data.

Are you seeking a waste and energy analysis for your business? We can help you.